To MacBook Air or not MacBook Air that is the question
Author: realmac // Category: ComputingFirst a little bit of background. I’ve been using Apple laptops for the past 9 years. Overall they have served my needs remarkably well, with the exception of the 1st iBook/500 I had which was ungodly slow. My current system is a 17 inch MacBook Pro with a 2.8 GHz Core 2 Duo processor, a 500 GB 5400 RPM hard drive and an upgrade to 8 GB of memory (which I installed almost a year ago and March).
When I got the system, I was thinking that I could have a computer serve all my entertainment needs and didn’t actually have television or DVR in my room. Flash forward a few years, now I have and find the experience much more pleasurable than watching video on a computer screen.
I also discovered that having a 17 inch laptop is not all it’s cracked up to be, especially if you actually use it in your lap or plan to carry it around with you. Mine is bulky, somewhat heavy at 6.6 pounds and tends to get rather warm when I have the Nvidia GeForce 9600 graphics chip enabled, something I tend to do for higher performance.
Though the 800 pound gorilla in the room is performance, my hard drive it is definitely on the slow side, taking 30 bounces of GarageBand before I can open the program. Even with the extra RAM, I really notice a difference in programs that are constantly writing to the disk.
Results above are mine, drive is running at 1.5Gigabit, below are from a MacBook Air. A disk on a 6Gb SATA that reads 5x faster, affecting so many different aspects of my computing experience. Very compelling.
I would like to upgrade to solid-state technology, but am not entirely sure how much I’m sold for the capacity I want. I’m looking at a 256 GB unit from Crucial that runs about $339 USD. I’m also at a point in my life where I want to do the financially responsible thing and spending that much for a computer upgrade seems a little bit on the excessive side. Specifically with the CPU already being generation old and the graphics card about 2 generations old and incapable of being upgraded. On the reverse side, I could use his hard drive and another system and sell it with the original when the time comes.
Crucial M4 CT256M4SSD2 2.5″ 256GB SATA III MLC Internal Solid State Drive (SSD)
Two other factors that process on my mind are Intel’s microprocessor roadmap and soon to come updates to the MacBook model line. There’s nothing worse than having buyer’s remorse right after buying a tech gadget because something else has eclipsed it. Of course there’ll always be something bigger faster or otherwise more enticing, it’s the nature of the beast.
Newer laptops will have 4K video acceleration built into the chipset (It sounds good in theory, but am not sure in practice with US high speed bandwidth already straining with current 1080P video), higher resolution ‘Retina’ displays, and as far as Macs go possibly a departure from the current unibody design. Some of the changes are over a year away and others even if they are available will command a high price premium. Either of which would not affect my decision very heavily. Shit happens, get a grip.
Does it make financial sense to switch from my current system to one of the smaller screen but higher overall perceived performance?
When I purchased the 17 inch MacBook Pro in summer of 2009, I paid approximately $2200 for it, not including the memory upgrade, a Speck case, an inexpensive SATA enclosure and PCI express card. Today February 2012 on eBay a system with similar specs will sell for approximately $1300, excluding shipping charges and eBay / PayPal fees. Between educational/corporate discounts and shopping I can get a MacBook Air 13 Core i5, 4gb, 256gb flash and Intel HD Graphics for 1498 with a $50 restaurant.com gift card and 2.5% cashback from FatWallet. I’m also pretty sure there would be no state sales tax for me.
Thoughts welcome. I’ve had way too many laptops over the years. This one will probably last me a year or two before I sell it and get something else. Also Macs hold their value pretty well. Probably more so on the low end than the high end percentage-wise. $150-200 for a new machine isn’t that much.
I did own a MacBook Air about 4 years ago, but sold it because its performance did not live up to my expectations. It had an 80 GB 4200 RPM hard drive, 2 GB of RAM 1.6 GHz core 2 Duo processor and a really paltry GMA X3100 graphics card. The fans would rev up into high gear whenever I would look at a video on YouTube. Other than that the machine was super quiet and felt like I wasn’t even using a computer.
Carrying 6.6lb around vs 2.96 is a pretty big difference. It may not sound like it, but when balancing the machine on your palm, or on your back there is a perceivable difference immediately. I’m still not sure what I want to do yet. Waiting and seeing does have its merits sometimes. A hardware refresh would also make it a much easier decision. I could also keep the drive I have now, pull out my SuperDrive and throw the SSD in my laptop and have two drives. Decisions…
There is always the possibility I’ll never be satisfied with my choice. So maybe it’s easier to accept there will always be something I don’t like and just hold onto my hw as long as it still makes sense.
Just to recap…
MacBook Pro 17:
Pros: 8gb ram, 500gb hard drive, room to put two hard drives if I want, beautiful display, will not lose any money if I upgrade the drive (can put it in another machine a year from now if I upgrade), high resolution 1080p display, great battery life.
Cons: Not very portable / heavy, slower SATA controller technology, system gets extremely hot when GeForce 9600m activated, hard to keep in lap because of bulk, Core 2 Duo lacks HyperThreading and uses much more power than i5/i7.
MacBook Air:
Pros: Super super fast SSD technology, lightweight, fits in any kind of bag, runs very cool, whisper quiet.
Cons: Even though it’s a new system, not much of a gaming machine, somewhat dated 2008 design. Four years have passed… Makes me wonder what’s next, Ivy Bridge is just around the corner. Screen resolution only 1440 x 900. Fine for 720p but scales down for 1080p.
Update: I opted to stay with my 17″ MacBook Pro, upgraded to a 128gb Crucial m4 from Micro Center for $180 and put my 5400 rpm drive in the optical bay slot using a cheapo kit from Amazon. So far satisfying until Haswell comes along.
